So, here are the events as I understand them:
- Teenager organizes a pool party and posts it on social media, and naturally everyone shows up.
- Pool party is in clear violation of the HOA rules that state that each member of the community is allowed a maximum of two guests with a key card.
- Kids are denied entry and get upset. They start jumping the fence. A couple of fights break out. Parents complain about vulgar music in the presence of their young children.
- Security guard is overwhelmed and calls the police.
- Meanwhile, an adult allegedly begins tossing out racial slurs, things get heated, and someone gets slapped.
- This took place in a very quiet community with an extremely low crime rate. As most of the kids knew each other, they were almost all from the area.
OK, so these kids, at least the majority of them, were being stupid. I'm sure I can find at least 500 articles from the last year in Texas about house parties getting out of hand, police being called, and teenagers getting arrested. This has probably been happening since the dawn of time. My parents grew up in the 50's and 60's and they have their fair share of stories.
Let's all acknowledge right now that teenagers do stupid things, and they do them with greater frequency and intensity in large groups. Let's all acknowledge that we did stupid things when we were teenagers, and we probably dug ourselves deeper by mouthing off to at least one authority figure. This is what teenagers do. I'm not going to bother to cite sources here, because I believe you all have Google, but we know that this is part of development in kids. Teenagers do not yet have fully developed brains. Many of them have poor impulse control.
This doesn't mean that we let them get away with these things. We should be teaching them how to appropriately deal with authority figures. I've had kids mouth off at me. I've broken up a large group of teenagers in the hall watching a fight (and found myself in the middle of two girls fighting once) and not once did I ever put my hands on a kid. I have written referrals for kids who like to argue with teachers, or run from teachers when they're in trouble. I've also never run after a kid, and they usually got caught anyway. Funny how that works out.
The sane cop shown in the video, the one who accepts the flashlight that the kids pick up off the ground, has the right idea. He rationally talks to the kids and says "Hey, guys, you can't run from the cops. Have a seat please." And they do. He is a calm, authoritative person in an otherwise chaotic environment, and people respond. Meanwhile, crazy cop is running around screaming. And kids are running from him. Listen, guys, that's at least partially instinct. If something big and loud is coming at you, your body says run. And given his behavior throughout the video combined with recent events and their subsequent news coverage involving young men and police officers, if I were those kids, I probably would have run away, too. Let's also talk about they way he's addressing the kids. "Don't make me f*****' run around here with thirty pounds of ******* gear on, son!" "Get your *** over here!" "Get your *** home!" Who, exactly, is the professional adult in this situation?
Furthermore, as I understand it, the purpose of calling the police in the first place was to get the kids to leave. I can understand the need to control the crowd, but come on. If in fact the cops had arrived and the kids who were running had committed a crime, couldn't they have done some investigative work to track them down? Don't our tax dollars pay for that? Unless they were running away with kidnapped babies or something I fail to see the point in trying to corral that many kids.
As for the girl who was tackled to the ground: she got yanked around quite a bit. I didn't see what the initial provocation was, if any, because it was too far away from the view of the camera, but it looks like he heard a kid mouthing off and confronted her. Again, who is the adult here? And once she was sitting on the ground in tears, screaming about calling her mom, how hard would it have been to get her in handcuffs? Maybe hard. Sometimes when people are upset they resist being physically touched. But certainly not so hard that this officer had to put his knees into her back. On the concrete. While she was wearing a bikini. Haven't we already observed that this kind of restraint can cause serious injury?
A lot of people have argued that the cop was justified in pulling his weapon because there were two kids advancing on him and one of them looked like he was trying to pull a gun from the waistband of his pants. First of all, the officer was not alone on the scene (as evidenced by the two officers who immediately come to him after he draws his weapon, seemingly to get him to put it away). Second of all, if those kids were looking for a fight it was clearly to protect the girl who the officer was yanking around. Is it right? That's a tough one to call. On the one hand, he is a police officer. On the other, if she were your sister, or your girlfriend, or your cousin, what would you have done? Were the officer's actions right to begin with, and whose responsibility is it to step in when we see a police officer harming a citizen? Third, I'm no expert, but it didn't look to me like that kid was trying to pull a gun from his waistband. It didn't look like there was a gun in there. Have any of you watched teenage boys walk anywhere lately? That kid was pulling up his pants not two seconds before the "reach behind the back" move. He pulled up his pants from the back of his waistband. Nearly all teenage boys do this because nearly all teenage boys wear their pants halfway to their knees, and they have a nervous twitch about it. Go to the mall. Count the number of times you see teenage boys touch or adjust the backs of their shirts or their waistbands. I'm convinced that at this point it will be hardwired in the DNA of their offspring.
Besides all that-when someone pulls out a gun in a situation like this, against unarmed teenagers, people very understandably panic. The situation just kept escalating. I think that this officer should seek some counseling and find a different career. Maybe he's not a terrible person, but he probably isn't suited for police work. There are some situations in which I find myself reviewing the facts of the case as they are presented and making the conclusion that the police acted correctly, but this isn't one of them. Well-that one officer wasn't doing his job correctly. The others were, and thank goodness they stepped in when he pulled out a gun.
So my big question is this: what can we as citizens do in the moment to stop these things? I did see one man approach the girl who was tackled to the ground, presumably to ask if she was ok. There were two boys who attempted to physically defend her and that went horribly. There were people filming, including a fifteen year old boy who filmed the whole thing (good thinking, kid). But what if the video had ended with kids dying? Certainly it would be of use in a trial, but it wouldn't have saved anyone. Would anyone have responded in time if citizens had called the police...on the police? What if the other officers hadn't been there immediately after the gun was drawn? I don't know the answer, but I hope someone does. What if these had been your kids? Your students? Your cousins?


